From my living room window in Queens, I watch surging black and gray clouds
eat up the clear blue sky over Manhattan.
In my mind, I try to
match the smoke clouds to the images I see broadcast over and over again on
television. Though I know different, it seems as if the two cannot have
anything to do with one another. The smoke outside my window is so
close—just a few minute’s ride on the subway. The scene on the
television, in contrast, seems like it must be in some far away land. Like
the one I was born in.
On my television
screen, pictures of the World Trade Center towers burning like candles are
eventually replaced with images of them crumbling like sand castles. I sit
watching the TV without really hearing the newscasters. My stomach churns,
and my anxiety builds on so many levels.
My first thought: Do I
know anyone who works in those towers? I make some phone calls, send out
some e-mails, and in short order am assured that my friends and loved ones
are safe. I sigh momentary relief and try not to wonder how many people
might have been in the buildings when they collapsed into graveyards of
concrete and steel.
My second thought: Who
did this? And my stomach churns again, for different, more complicated
reasons.
Almost immediately,
even without any evidence to suggest it, newscasters and talking heads
speculate that the horror was the work of “Palestinian terrorists.”
Later, that turns out to be false, and the talk turns instead to Osama bin
Laden. As a Palestinian-American, I try to find what little relief there
might be in the fact that a Palestinian group wasn’t involved. But a
lifetime of living in America doesn’t let me rest.
I know that to most
Americans, an Arab is an Arab is an Arab. Even worse, I know the inevitable
backlash that lies ahead for anyone of Arab origin. For too many people now,
all Arabs, all Muslims will be the enemy.
This ugly brand of
guilt by association seems especially reserved for Arabs and Muslims. When
the fair-skinned Timothy McVeigh and his cohorts bombed the Federal Building
in Oklahoma City—spouting their particular twist of Christianity—white,
Midwestern men felt no shame or guilt or connection to the crime. When the
Irish Republican Army attacks a British target, American newscasters do not
paint all Catholics as religious fanatics.
I know the same will
not be true for Arabs and Muslims.
In the days that
follow, my fears turn into reality. Frightening reports pour in from across
the country. In Texas, at least three mosques are attacked with makeshift
bombs.
In Seattle, a man rams
a truck into a mosque and opens gunfire. In Illinois, an angry mob of 300
rampage through an Arab neighborhood. In Detroit, an Arab-American newspaper
editor is deluged with death threats. In Brooklyn, Muslim women who cover
their heads with scarves are chased and beaten.
Now on the TV news I
see a woman waving an American flag and screaming, “They don’t deserve
to live here! They don’t deserve to live!” She stares into the camera
and calls herself a “real American.”
Of my 37 years, I have
spent all but six in America. My mother was as American as they come, a poor
Southern Baptist farm girl from Georgia. My father, a naturalized citizen,
spent nearly 40 years in this country. Though born in Palestine, I have been
an American citizen since I took my first breath in this world.
Yet my entire life, I
have always been made to feel that I am not a “real American.” I have
always struggled with my dual identities, part Palestinian, part American,
alternately loving and hating each, but always clinging as best I could to
both.
And now, when I most
need my Americanism, I am pushed furthest from it. If I am completely
honest, I will admit that after this latest, horrific attack, I am made to
feel less like an American than ever before in my life.
And that makes me
angry. After all, New York is my city, too. I live here, work here, play
here, love here, like anyone else. As I got the news of planes crashing into
the World Trade Center and the Pentagon and rural Pennsylvania, I watched in
horror and worried about friends and loved ones and shook in disbelief, too.
Yet I was not allowed
to grieve as an American. Instead, I was instantly forced on the defensive
as an Arab.
The day of the attack,
a hand-scribbled cardboard sign appears in a local store window, just one
block from my apartment. “Nuke them all!” the message thunders, and I
know its venom is meant for me, too.
I walk down the familiar, once comfortable
streets of my neighborhood, and it is not international terrorists who pose
the most immediate threat to my well-being. I overhear the suspicion and
hatred in other people’s conversations toward all things Arab, all things
Muslim. And I am genuinely frightened. Yes, I am frightened for myself as an
Arab, but I am also frightened for my country—as an American.
Mubarak Dahir receives email at